Full diagnostic chain — every step, prompt, and reference image traced from origins to published spread
This prompt generated both d10-mm-p3-v1.jpg (character ref — "favorite Ollie") and d10-mm-p3-v2.jpg (style benchmark ref). Both are variant outputs from the same prompt — visual differences are from model randomness.
Reference images fed in:
Output variants:
March 26, 2026 · 4 concept variants · No reference images used
LIKED
March 26, 2026 · 10 variations with updated characters · Used vertical_descent as reference
V01
4 variants with D14B style references · Text prompts with 4 different descriptions
4 variants · Same batch as page04 above · Deeper descent scene
6 variants focused specifically on the descent scene
2 variants · Further descent explorations
March 27, 2026 · 4 of 10 variants shown · Feedback-corrected prompt with Ollie ref
2 variants · Happy expression exploration
2 variants · Deeper descent exploration
2 variants · Dive composition exploration
2 variants · Page 18 descent scene
2 variants · Page 18 descent scene
March 27-28, 2026 · 2 incline/descent variants · First iteration with v1 prompt
March 28, 2026 17:28 UTC · Replicate NBP · Batch 3 of 4 · 2 variants · V2 selected for the printed book
CHAR REF
STYLE REF
SELECTED
BOOK
March 28, 2026 · Further variants after V20 pick · V21 = book-editor v2.jpg/v2(1).jpg, V22 = 6 final variants
CHAR REF
STYLE REF
5 variants · 1 page04 + 4 page18 descent scenes
The scene that was restyled · Book page 7 · Draft 1 era · See full origin trace in Section 0c above
ORIGINAL
March 31, 2026 · Nano Banana Pro · Google AI Studio free tier · v2 of 4 selected
ZOOM LEVEL
TARGET
Selected
STYLE REF
Top 1
Top 2
Top 3
8 images · gemini-3.1-flash (NB2) · temp 0.85–1.01 · No image refs — pure text prompt
Honorable
8 images · gemini-3.1-flash (NB2) · Stage 1 best outputs used as anchors
Honorable
16 images · Nano Banana Pro · Model upgrade from NB2 · Stage 2 best as anchor
Pick #2
8.0
Honorable
11 images · Nano Banana Pro · Stage 3 best as anchors · Top pick: V08 (8.5)
Top Pick
8.5
Honorable
CHAR REF
REF IMAGE
REF IMAGE
QUALITY TARGET
STYLE
COMP
CHAR
QUALITY
8.2
8.8
9.0
Perfect
10.0
9.3
8.2
9.3
7.3 FAIL
8.3
9.9
Perfect
10.0
9.1
7.7
9.1
9.1
Perfect
10.0
Selected p21_s07_v4.png as the base for refinement
BASE
4 variants · NB2 (gemini-3.1-flash) · temp 0.85–1.0 · Edit-based generation
SELECTED
4 variants · NB2 (gemini-3.1-flash) · temp 0.85–1.0 · Edit-based generation
SELECTED FOR BOOK
Generated March 26, 2026 · Nano Banana 2 (NB2) via Replicate · iterate mode · Reference images: ollie_pick.png (Ollie character) + dot_pick_agata.png (Dot character)
AGATA'S FAVORITE OLLIE
STYLE BENCHMARK
Draft Pick
CHAR REF
STYLE REF
Selected
STYLE + SCENE REF
CHAR
Favorite
generate_spread04_p3.py · STYLE_REF = current-pages/spread04_sunny_reef.png · OLLIE_REF = character-refs-v5/ollie/3d-r4/3d_ollie_nbp_v2.png · Prompt: "The first reference image shows the current scene composition and rendering style to match and improve upon."
STYLE + COMP
CHAR
Winner
★ NAILS IT
STYLE (P3 Winner)
CHAR
10/10
Top Pick
10/10
Top Pick
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
9/10
Top Pick
10/10
Top Pick
10/10
9/10
Top Pick
10/10
Top Pick
10/10
10/10
8/10
CHAR REF
image_1: d10-mm-p3-v1.jpg (Ollie character) · image_2: d10-mixed-media-p3/v2.jpg (Style)
REF 1
REF 2
March 28, 2026 17:50 UTC · Replicate NBP · 2 front cover variants in this batch · V2 selected as book cover
SELECTED
BOOK COVER
public/images/nbp-v21/front_cover_v2.jpg — 2752x1536 (EC2 original)book-editor/images/front_cover_v2.jpg — 2752x1536 (AI Studio copy 1)book-editor/images/front_cover_v2 (1).jpg — 2752x1536 (Chrome re-download)01_front_cover_v2_(1).jpg_202603292213.jpeg — book-editor numbered (AI Studio timestamp: Mar 29, 22:13)book-drafts/.../01_front_cover_v2_(1).jpg_202603292213.jpeg — Draft 1 full-pages setdraft-2/progression/cover/refs/draft1_cover.jpg — progression reference copy
REF 1 — CHAR
REF 2 — STYLE
Book Cover
REF 1 — CHAR
REF 2 — STYLE
REF 3 — QUALITY
Selected
Pick 1
Pick 1
Page 10 in Draft 1 era · March 29, 2026
ORIGINAL



















































Pick 1
Page 8 in Draft 1 era · Dot's blue glow pearlescent · March 29, 2026
ORIGINAL
STORYBOARD

























REF IMAGE
REF IMAGE
REF IMAGE
Selected
Pick 1
edit12_nameit/ · Selected favorites from early generation
FAV
FAV
FAV
Reference images used (Pipeline 2):
FAV
FAV
FAV
FAV
FAV
FAV
FAV
Reference image used (Pipeline 6): Prompt says "Use the reference image ONLY for character quality, mood, and artistic style."
Generation details (Pipelines 37–41): No separate prompt files found for these pipelines. They used the R6 base prompt from the corrected batch (Section 1 above) with progressive pipeline-level refinements. JPG output format (earlier pipelines used PNG).
Source refs for pipelines 37-41: These later pipelines likely used outputs from earlier pipelines (P2, P6) as style/composition references, with the R6 base prompt driving scene content. No refs_used.txt files were found — ref lineage is inferred from pipeline progression.
















SCENE REF













































Reference images used (C4):








Draft-2: pipeline2, pipeline3, pipeline5, pipeline6, pipeline7, pipeline8, pipeline9, pipeline10, pipeline11, pipeline20, pipeline21, pipeline22, pipeline37, pipeline38, pipeline39, pipeline40, pipeline41
Draft-3: nbp-batch1 (5), batch16 (8), batch-new (3), batch-v2 (3), batch4 (4), batch4-redo (4), batch5-ref-test (8), batch5-ref-test-v2 (8), C4 generation (8)
4 concept variants: mother_and_calf, vast_journey, whale_song, whale_world
LIKED
4 concept variants · same scene names, refined
4 concept variants · whale_world used as composition ref for Round 3 master prompt
COMP REF
COMP REF
March 27, 2026 · Exploring whale composition, sound, scale, lighting
Earliest NBP attempt at whale scene




Targeted whale song generation


Continued whale composition refinement


Single generation in V20 batch

Last Replicate NBP generation for this spread

First Gemini NB2 generation round




Second Gemini NB2 generation round




NBP model generation round

TOP 1

Final NBP generation round


TOP 3
AI-scored best variants from 4 rounds
TOP 1
TOP 2
TOP 3Refined edit output selected from multiple sub-batches






















































Original book illustration · Starting point for all refinements
Mixed-media collage · 2:1 aspect · NB2 + NBP variants
Macro scale · Corrected eyes · Dot sizing
16 NB2 variants · Continued refinement from P2
STYLE REF
CHAR REF
Sunny Reef continuity · DOT description fix · NB2 on Gemini
EDIT SOURCE
p21_s05_v1 became composition reference for Pipeline 28
LIKED
STYLE REF
COMP REF
Script: p28_spread05.py · DTS style reference + Hide & Seek composition
Photorealistic seagrass · Smaller hidden Dot · Used p28_s05_v3 as comp ref
LIKED
True Collage Mixed Media Diorama · p44_s05_v4 selected as PICK
PICK
Original book illustration · Starting point for all refinements
Asymmetric canyon edge · 2:1 aspect · Mixed media collage
Corrected eyes · GOLD/SILVER foil distinction
16 NB2 variants · Continued from P2
STYLE REF
CHAR REF
edge_full.txt (standard) + edge_combined.txt (all creator feedback)
4 prompt directions: jumping, vertigo, wide canyon, action leap · p11_s06_v4 became COMP ref for P43
LIKED
4 variants · Continued edge refinement
COMP + CHAR REF
P44 v1 selected as PICK
PICK
Original book illustration · Starting point for all refinements
Deep ocean · Bioluminescent · Dot with BLUE glow
Dot changed to YELLOW joy eyes · “SUPER JOYOUS” · Floating/swirling
16 NB2 variants generated with Edge/Cliff prompt instead of Glowing Fish prompt
STYLE REF
COMP REF
CHAR REF
First CORRECT Glowing Fish generation · WOW page · Ollie looking UP
Best Glowing Fish result before the final ClarityEnhance pipeline
LIKED
p37_s08_v1 selected as PICK · Van Gogh Starry Night bioluminescent effect
PICK
Used P37 v2 as input · Not an ancestor of the final pick · Exploration branch
Style ref + Composition ref + Character ref — fed into all early corrected-batch pipelines
COMP REF
STYLE REF
CHAR REF
April 2026 · NB2 · Style + comp + char refs · First corrected-batch outputs
16 variants · Refined shadow scene · NB2
Style ref + comp ref only · Character ref dropped to fix sticker effect
Clarity and backlighting emphasis
Watercolor whale shadow treatment
April 27, 2026 · Natural blended whale shadow · V3 selected as top pick
TOP PICK
Later pipeline after P40 pick · True watercolor rendering
STYLE REF
OLLIE REF
DOT REF
First 3D photorealistic macro style with 3 character/style refs
Refined 3D: whale shadow as barely-noticeable darker tone, darkest page emphasis
Refs: p40_s09_v3.jpg (composition) + o2_reaching.png (style)
Ref: o2_reaching.png only — no composition guidance
Dedicated character reference approach
Photorealistic macro with camera specs and FORBIDDEN list
Trimmed/simplified prompt · Temperature 0.85 for more consistent outputs
Latest iteration of the Giant Shadow scene
pipeline2, pipeline3, pipeline5, pipeline6, pipeline7, pipeline8, pipeline10, pipeline11, pipeline20, pipeline21, pipeline22, pipeline23, pipeline24, pipeline28, pipeline29, pipeline37, pipeline38, pipeline40, pipeline42
Style ref + Composition ref + Character ref — fed into all early corrected-batch pipelines
COMP REF
STYLE REF
CHAR REF
April 2026 · NB2 · First corrected-batch outputs for whale reveal
16 variants · Refined whale reveal scene
No reference images — pure text generation
April 27, 2026 · V2 selected as top pick for spread 12
TOP PICK
Post-pick pipeline · Continued iteration
STYLE REF
OLLIE REF
DOT REF
First 3D photorealistic macro style — emotional release from fear to wonder
Refs: p44_s12_v2.jpg (composition) + o2_reaching.png (style)
Ref: o2_reaching.png only — no composition guidance
Dedicated character reference approach
Photorealistic macro with camera specs and FORBIDDEN list
Trimmed/simplified prompt · Temperature 0.85 for consistency
Refined whale reveal in 3D macro style
Latest iteration of the Whale Reveal scene
pipeline2, pipeline3, pipeline5, pipeline6, pipeline7, pipeline8, pipeline9, pipeline10, pipeline11, pipeline20, pipeline21, pipeline22, pipeline40, pipeline44, pipeline45
P35 used page01-style-ref.jpg (mixed media collage target) · Earlier pipelines used edit17 style + spread17 comp + Ollie char
COMP REF
STYLE REF (P35)
STYLE REF (early)
CHAR REF
April 2026 · NB2 · First corrected-batch outputs for going home
15 variants · Refined homecoming scene
Fresh celebration scene approach
Detailed regeneration with refined prompts
April 26, 2026 · Mixed media collage regen with page01-style-ref.jpg · V3 selected as top pick
TOP PICK
STYLE REF
OLLIE REF
DOT REF
First 3D photorealistic macro style — pure joy and celebration
Warm color palette · Abundance/party scene · Sunset coral reef
Trimmed/simplified prompt · Temperature 0.85 for consistency
Latest iteration of the Celebration scene
pipeline2, pipeline3, pipeline5, pipeline7, pipeline8, pipeline9, pipeline10, pipeline11, pipeline20, pipeline21, pipeline22, pipeline23, pipeline24, pipeline27, pipeline28, pipeline29, pipeline30, pipeline31, pipeline32, pipeline33, pipeline34, pipeline35, pipeline36, pipeline41, pipeline44, pipeline45
spread19_how_feeling.png · Original illustration for Interactive Breathing scene
ORIGIN
24 variants · NB2 · Earliest exploration · 4 of 24 shown
r7_generate.py · Using earlier pipeline outputs as refs
REF→P8
pipeline8_gen.py · build_s15_prompt() · Mixed-media collage, emotion bubbles, 3D Ollie
REF→P10
NB2 · Edit of P8 V1 with P9 corrections
Extended exploration with multiple temperature/ref combinations
DetailedRegen · Final selected image for this spread
PICK
spread20_big_feelings.png · Original illustration for Ending / Shell Closed scene
ORIGIN
24 variants · NB2 · Earliest exploration · 4 of 24 shown
Large batch · No script preserved (predates structured approach) · 4 of 16 shown
REF→P10
NB2 · Edit of P3-S17_v12.png with nighttime P9 corrections
Continued refinement from P10 outputs
"Starry Bioluminescence" · NB2 · Temperature 0.90
PICK
spread23_back_cover.png · Original hand-designed back cover
ORIGIN
21 variants · NB2 · Earliest exploration · 4 of 21 shown
Large batch · Predates structured script approach
Intermediate refinement step
NB2 · Edit of spread23_back_cover.png with P9 corrections · V2 = temp 0.95
PICK
Originally generated as an environment "back spread" page (no characters) during NBP v20 batch. The founder said "this image is great so nothing" — it was kept as-is and later placed as the Note for Grown-Ups background.
Reference image:
Output:
Reference image: spread21_note_grownups.jpg (original artwork)
Reference image: P3-S17_v12.png (Pipeline 3 output above)